IMAGE PROTECTION WHEN A CITIZEN IS AT PUBLIC EVENTS (ARTICLE 152.1 OF THE CIVIL CODE OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION)
https://doi.org/10.24412/2225-8264-2024-2-736
Abstract
The right of a citizen to an image from the point of view of legislative regulation is relatively new for the domestic law and order. Therefore, the application of the legal norms introduced by Federal Law No. 231 of December 18, 2006 raises a number of questions both in theory and in practice. One of them is how a person can determine the nature of the event held by the organizer in order not to violate the right to image citizens who find themselves at the venue of the relevant event, while fixing and distributing their images. Purpose: based on the analysis of the norms of current legislation, doctrinal sources, and law enforcement practice, to propose an approach to determining the nature of the event as private or public. Methods: general scientific and private scientific research methods were used: formal and dialectical logic, methods of description, comparison, interpretation, legal-dogmatic and method of interpretation of legal norms. Results: it has been established that both in theory and in law enforcement practice, difficulties arise in characterizing events as public. For civil law purposes (art. 152.1 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation) the concept of a public event covers any events accessible to an indefinite number of people, held in public or other places. Conclusions: accessibility and freedom of attendance is one of the important signs of a public event. The private or public nature of the event must be determined by its organizers.
About the Author
E. A. Khodyreva
Udmurt State University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Ekaterina A. Khodyreva, Doctor of Law, Associate Professor
References
1. The UN warned about the danger of chatbots with AI for humanity. URL: https://versia.ru/v-oon-predupredili-ob-opasnosti-chat-botov-s-ii-dlya-chelovechestva (access date: 02/12/2024).
2. World News in Brief: Artificial intelligence pledge, child abuse online, Sudan crisis deepens. URL: https://news.un.org/en/story/2024/02/1146217 (access date: 02/12/2024).
3. The Civil Code of the Russian Federation (Part one): Federal Law No. 51-FZ dated 11/30/1994. Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation. 1994; 32: St. 3301.
4. Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation dated 06/23/2015 No. 25 "On the application by Courts of certain Provisions of Section I of Part One of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation". Bulletin of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation. 2015; 8.
5. Sitdikova R. I. Ensuring private, public and public interests by copyright / scientific ed. M. Yu. Chelyshev. M.: Statut, 2013. 159 p. // Legal reference and information system «ConsultantPlus».
6. Ivanov I. Portrait of the unknown. E`Zh-Yurist = EJ is A Lawyer. 2012; 47: 13. (In Russ.).
7. Puzanov I. Video camera in the law? E`Zh-Yurist = EJ is A Lawyer. 2012; 8: 10. (In Russ.).
8. Volkov V. E. Electoral identification: the limits of individualization of participants in the electoral process. Lex russica. 2015; 10: 46-56. (In Russ.).
9. Nikitin V. V. Biometric personal data of employees. Otdel kadrov gosudarstvennogo (municipal`nogo) uchrezhdeniya = The personnel department of the state (municipal) institution. 2018; 9: 11-20. (In Russ.).
10. Federal Law No. 54-FZ of 06/19/2004 (as amended on 12/05/2022) "On Assemblies, Rallies, demonstrations, marches and picketing". Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation. 2004; 25: St. 2485.
11. Constitution of the Russian Federation (adopted by popular vote on 12/12/1993 with amendments approved during the all-Russian vote 01.07.2020) // URL: http://www.pravo.gov.ru, 04.07.2020. (access date: 12/01/2023).
12. The Code of Administrative Offences of the Russian Federation: Federal Law No. 195-FZ dated 12/30/2001. Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation. 2002; 1 (ch. 1): St. 1.
13. Ruling of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation dated 10/24/2013 No. 1721-O "On refusal to accept for consideration the complaint of citizen Alexey Vitalievich Sherstyuk for violation of his constitutional rights by the provisions of Part 1 of Article 3.5 and Part 1 of Article 20.2.2 of the Code of the Russian Federation on administrative offenses" // Legal reference and information system «ConsultantPlus».
14. Federal Law No. 64-FZ dated 04/06/2011 (as amended on 12/25/2023) "On administrative supervision of persons released from places of deprivation of liberty". Collection of Legislation of the Russian Federation. 2011; 15: St. 2037.
15. Decision of the Lukoyanovsky District Court (Nizhny Novgorod region) dated 09/10/2020 in case No. 2A-578/2020 // URL: https://sudact.ru/regular/doc/ZOnQ8QJKPglW/ (access date: 03/15/2024).
16. Decision of the Lukoyanovsky District Court (Nizhny Novgorod region dated 09.09.2020 in case No. 2A-576/2020 // URL: https://sudact.ru/regular/doc/5byJr2bf9lZQ (access date: 03/15/2024).
17. Decision of the Lukoyanovsky District Court (Nizhny Novgorod region) dated 04.09.2020 in case No. 2A-597/2020 // URL: https://sudact.ru/regular/doc/iC1esCEwly5V (access date: 03/15/2024).
18. Decision of the Zavolzhsky District Court of Ulyanovsk (Ulyanovsk region) dated 30.07.2020 in case No. 2A-2799/2020 // URL: https://sudact.ru/regular/doc/3H678sMnHW1u (access date: 03/15/2024).
19. The appeal ruling of the Sverdlovsk Regional Court dated 10/31/2023 in case No. 33a-18156/2023 // Legal reference and information system «ConsultantPlus».
20. Vanyushin Ya. L., Galkin V. A., Filatova A. V. Commentary on Federal Law No. 64-FZ dated April 6, 2011 "On Administrative supervision of persons released from places of deprivation of liberty" (article by article) / edited by S. A. Denisov // Legal reference and information system «ConsultantPlus».
21. Paragraph 30 of the Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation dated 05/16/2017 No. 15 (ed. dated 12/22/2022) "On some issues arising during the consideration by courts of cases on administrative supervision of persons released from places of deprivation of liberty". Bulletin of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation. 2017; 7.
22. Ruling of the Second Cassation Court of General Jurisdiction dated 09/21/2023 No. 88-23107/2023 in case No. 2-4993/2022 // Legal reference and information system «ConsultantPlus».
23. The decision of the Industrial District Court of Smolensk (Smolensk region) dated 01/22/2020 in case No. 2-3449/2019 // URL: https://sudact.ru/regular/doc/DsJONfN2qZZi/?regular-txt=®ular-case_doc=2-3449%2F2019+®ular-lawchunkinfo=®ular-date_from=®ular-date_to=®ular-workflow_stage=®ular-area=®ular-court=Промышленный+районный+суд+г.+Смоленска+%28Смоленская+область%29®ular-judge=&_=1711376393467 (date of access: 03/20/2024).
24. The decision of the Oryol Regional Court (Oryol region) dated 04/14/2021 in the case № 2-1-43/2021(2-1-943/2020;)~ M-1-847/2020 // URL: https://sudact.ru/regular/doc/kKdmlXpn9bNb/?regular-txt=®ular-case_doc=2-1-43%2F2021%282-1-943%2F2020%3B%29~М-1-847%2F2020+®ular-lawchunkinfo=®ular-date_from=®ular-date_to=®ular-workflow_stage=®ular-area=®ular-court=Орловский+областной+суд+%28Орловская+область%29®ular-judge=&_=1711376531410 (access date: 03/15/2024).
25. The appeal ruling of the Voronezh Regional Court dated 08/11/2022 in the case № 33-4431/2022, 2-219/2022 // Legal reference and information system «ConsultantPlus».
26. The ruling of the First Cassation Court of General Jurisdiction dated 01/18/2023 on the case № 88-3356/2023, 88-36769/2022 // Legal reference and information system «ConsultantPlus».
Review
For citations:
Khodyreva E.A. IMAGE PROTECTION WHEN A CITIZEN IS AT PUBLIC EVENTS (ARTICLE 152.1 OF THE CIVIL CODE OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION). Herald of Siberian Institute of Business and Information Technologies. 2024;13(2):149-155. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24412/2225-8264-2024-2-736
Views:
114
Email this article 